Shows were right on Baker Mayfield 12% of the time in 2026 — 5 of 42 verified calls across 8 shows.
One of the hardest players to call in 2026 — shows average 50% overall.
| FantasyPros Podcast | 3 of 25 · 12% |
| Fantasy Football Today | 2 of 9 · 22% |
| RotoWire Fantasy Football | 0 of 2 |
| The Fantasy Footballers | 0 of 2 |
| The Fantasy Football Show | 0 of 1 |
| Oak | 0 of 1 |
| 4for4 Football Podcast | 0 of 1 |
| Fantasy Football Counselor | 0 of 1 |
Percentages shown only once a show has 5+ scored calls on this player — below that, counts only.
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
6.7
HIT ✓
6.7 pts · startable line 18.0
"Mayfield is a middling quarterback 2 again this week"
RotoWire Fantasy Football
Week 7 · 2026
6.7
MISS
6.7 pts · startable line 18.0
"Yeah, I think he does play."
The Fantasy Footballers
Week 7 · 2026
6.7
MISS
6.7 pts · startable line 18.0
"I like Baker Mayfield immediately off of your waiver wire against the Carolina Panthers"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 4 · 2026
—
Void
"Go back to the Mayfield well again this week if you need risky upside."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
12.3
MISS
12.3 pts · startable line 20.8
"Go back to the Mayfield well again this week if you need risky upside."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
12.3
MISS
12.3 pts · startable line 20.8
"Go back to the Mayfield well again this week if you need risky upside."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
12.3
MISS
12.3 pts · startable line 20.8
"Go back to the Mayfield well again this week if you need risky upside."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
12.3
MISS
12.3 pts · startable line 20.8
"Go back to the Mayfield well again this week if you need risky upside."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
12.3
MISS
12.3 pts · startable line 20.8
"Go back to the Mayfield well again this week if you need risky upside."
Fantasy Football Today
Week 3 · 2026
12.3
HIT ✓
12.3 pts · startable line 20.8
"Here comes Brian Flores. Stay very far away."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
12.3
MISS
12.3 pts · startable line 20.8
"Mayfield should go full savage mode in week 2 against his former team"
Fantasy Football Today
Week 2 · 2026
13.2
HIT ✓
13.2 pts · startable line 19.7
"A book is probably a maybe start guy."
The Fantasy Football Show
Week 2 · 2026
13.2
MISS
13.2 pts · startable line 19.7
"I'm starting Baker over May this week."
Fantasy Football Today
Week 2 · 2026
13.2
MISS
13.2 pts · startable line 19.7
"Baker or Stafford? Baker."
Fantasy Football Today
Week 2 · 2026
13.2
MISS
13.2 pts · startable line 19.7
"I was starting Baker over Goff. You know, I regret that one."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 2 · 2026
13.2
MISS
13.2 pts · startable line 19.7
"Mayfield should go full savage mode in Week 2 against his former team"
Fantasy Football Today
Week 2 · 2026
13.2
MISS
13.2 pts · startable line 19.7
"I would start Baker over Jared Goff."
RotoWire Fantasy Football
Week 2 · 2026
13.2
MISS
13.2 pts · startable line 19.7
"I'm still going Baker over Carson Wentz here."
The Fantasy Footballers
Week 2 · 2026
13.2
MISS
13.2 pts · startable line 19.7
"Would you play Goff or Baker? Goff."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 2 · 2026
13.2
MISS
13.2 pts · startable line 19.7
"Mayfield should be in an ornery mood this week, and he is usually at his best when there is sand in his britches."
Fantasy Football Today
Week 2 · 2026
13.2
MISS
13.2 pts · startable line 19.7
"if Baker does what he did early in the season last year in this game, which I think he will because I think they're going to have the ball a lot. You just saw Trevor Lawrence have four touchdowns against this defense. I think Baker could be a top 10 fantasy quarterback."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 2 · 2026
13.2
MISS
13.2 pts · startable line 19.7
"Mayfield should go full savage mode in Week 2 against his former team that ran him out of town after he played hurt during his tenure."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 2 · 2026
13.2
MISS
13.2 pts · startable line 19.7
"Mayfield should go full savage mode in week 2 against his former team that ran him out of town after he played hurt during his tenure."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 2 · 2026
13.2
MISS
13.2 pts · startable line 19.7
"I am rolling with him again this week."
Oak
Week 2 · 2026
13.2
MISS
13.2 pts · startable line 19.7
"I think Baker is a firm QB too"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 2 · 2026
13.2
MISS
13.2 pts · startable line 19.7
"Do not be shocked if Mayfield starts off the season with a top-five finish."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 2 · 2026
13.2
HIT ✓
13.2 pts · startable line 19.7
"it might be worth taking a wait-and-see approach with Mayfield."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 2 · 2026
13.2
MISS
13.2 pts · startable line 19.7
"Fire up Mayfield in week 2, who is looking to prove any doubters wrong."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 2 · 2026
13.2
HIT ✓
13.2 pts · startable line 19.7
"it might be worth taking a wait-and-see approach with Mayfield"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 2 · 2026
13.2
MISS
13.2 pts · startable line 19.7
"Mayfield should have a strong Week 1 performance"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 1 · 2026
11.6
MISS
11.6 pts · startable line 19.2
"Mayfield should have a strong week 1 performance."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 1 · 2026
11.6
MISS
11.6 pts · startable line 19.2
"Mayfield should have a strong Week 1 performance."
4for4 Football Podcast
Week 1 · 2026
11.6
MISS
11.6 pts · startable line 19.2
"Baker may feel that since he, I think it's another, uh, good spot"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 1 · 2026
11.6
MISS
11.6 pts · startable line 19.2
"Mayfield should have a strong week 1 performance, but I will also say that we need to throw every Cincy defensive statistic in the trash from 2025."
Fantasy Football Today
Week 1 · 2026
11.6
MISS
11.6 pts · startable line 19.2
"I love Baker this week."
Fantasy Football Today
Week 1 · 2026
11.6
MISS
11.6 pts · startable line 19.2
"Baker Mayfield has a chance to help fantasy managers if you do need a quarterback for week number one"
Fantasy Football Counselor
Week 1 · 2026
11.6
MISS
11.6 pts · startable line 19.2
"Baker Mayfield. Another solid matchup for him versus Cincy. I think he's going to have a great week."
Fantasy Football Today
Week 1 · 2026
11.6
MISS
11.6 pts · startable line 19.2
"Baker Mayfield, certainly over Mahomes"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 1 · 2026
11.6
MISS
11.6 pts · startable line 19.2
"Mayfield should have a strong week one performance"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 1 · 2026
11.6
MISS
11.6 pts · startable line 19.2
"Do not be shocked if Mayfield starts off the season with a top-five finish."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 1 · 2026
11.6
MISS
11.6 pts · startable line 19.2
"Mayfield should have a strong week-to-date"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 1 · 2026
11.6
MISS
11.6 pts · startable line 19.2
"Mayfield should have a strong Week 1 performance, but I will also say that we need to throw every Cincy defensive statistic in the trash from 2025."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 1 · 2026
11.6
MISS
11.6 pts · startable line 19.2
"Mayfield should have a strong week 1 performance"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 1 · 2026
—
Void
"Mayfield should have a strong week 1 performance"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 1 · 2026
—
Void
"Mayfield should have a strong, weak one performance"