Shows were right on Caleb Williams 18% of the time in 2026 — 6 of 33 verified calls across 7 shows.
One of the hardest players to call in 2026 — shows average 50% overall.
| FantasyPros Podcast | 2 of 17 · 12% |
| Fantasy Football Today | 2 of 8 · 25% |
| ESPN Fantasy Focus Football | 1 of 3 |
| RotoWire Fantasy Football | 0 of 2 |
| Good Old Boys Fantasy Football | 1 of 2 |
| Fantasy Points Podcast | 0 of 1 |
| Underdog Fantasy Football | 1 pending |
Percentages shown only once a show has 5+ scored calls on this player — below that, counts only.
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
22.1
HIT ✓
22.1 pts · startable line 18.0
"Must Start. These are no-brainer must-starts. Drake May, Caleb Williams, Dondre Swift."
Fantasy Football Today
Week 7 · 2026
22.1
HIT ✓
22.1 pts · startable line 18.0
"I think it'll be a little better than last week. I think he's a top 10 fantasy quarterback."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
22.1
HIT ✓
22.1 pts · startable line 18.0
"Must start. These are no-brainer must starts. Drake May, Caleb Williams, Dondre Swift."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 6 · 2026
16.5
MISS
16.5 pts · startable line 17.3
"Williams can still return QB1 production in a tough matchup with Ben Johnson at the controls."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 6 · 2026
16.5
MISS
16.5 pts · startable line 17.3
"Williams can still return QB1 production in a tough matchup with Ben Johnson at the controls."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 6 · 2026
16.5
MISS
16.5 pts · startable line 17.3
"Caleb Williams has an excellent matchup for a potential ceiling game, perfect for GPP if the roster ship stays reasonable."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 6 · 2026
16.5
MISS
16.5 pts · startable line 17.3
"Williams can still return QB1 production in a tough matchup with Ben Johnson at the controls."
ESPN Fantasy Focus Football
Week 6 · 2026
16.5
MISS
16.5 pts · startable line 17.3
"I'd play Caleb over Jacoby Brissett. I would agree with that."
ESPN Fantasy Focus Football
Week 6 · 2026
16.5
HIT ✓
16.5 pts · startable line 17.3
"I don't really want to start him this week."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 6 · 2026
16.5
MISS
16.5 pts · startable line 17.3
"Williams can still return QB1 production in a tough matchup with Ben Johnson at the controls."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 6 · 2026
16.5
MISS
16.5 pts · startable line 17.3
"Williams is expected back for the Bears' Week 6 game against the Falcons, who have been playing well after an 0-2 start. Atlanta has a pass-funnel defense."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 6 · 2026
16.5
MISS
16.5 pts · startable line 17.3
"Williams can still return quarterback when production in a tough matchup with Ben Johnson at the controls."
RotoWire Fantasy Football
Week 6 · 2026
16.5
MISS
16.5 pts · startable line 17.3
"It's Caleb. Caleb's a top 10 quarterback this week at Atlanta."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 6 · 2026
16.5
MISS
16.5 pts · startable line 17.3
"Williams can still return QB1 production in a tough matchup with Ben Johnson at the controls."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 6 · 2026
16.5
MISS
16.5 pts · startable line 17.3
"Williams can still return QB1 production in a tough matchup with Ben Johnson at the controls."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 6 · 2026
16.5
MISS
16.5 pts · startable line 17.3
"Williams can still return QB1 production in a tough matchup with Ben Johnson at the controls."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 6 · 2026
16.5
MISS
16.5 pts · startable line 17.3
"Williams can still return QB1 production in a tough matchup with Ben Johnson at the controls."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 6 · 2026
16.5
MISS
16.5 pts · startable line 17.3
"Williams can still return QB1 production in a tough matchup with Ben Johnson at the controls."
Good Old Boys Fantasy Football
Week 6 · 2026
16.5
HIT ✓
16.5 pts · startable line 17.3
"even if he does play i'm i'm pivoting elsewhere for a starting quarterback in fantasy"
RotoWire Fantasy Football
Week 5 · 2026
—
Void
"I would call it moderate that he does play in the sense that he logged a practice, a limited practice on Friday. Typically, when players do that, the vast majority play. About 70% of them end up playing the following week."
Underdog Fantasy Football
Week 5 · 2026
—
Void
"That sounds like we're going to get Caleb Williams back next week."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
—
Void
"Williams should be considered a decent QB2 this week, and anything more than that is just icing on the cake."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
—
Void
"Do I think Caleb Williams will play this week after last week's hamstring injury? No."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 2 · 2026
8.7
MISS
8.7 pts · startable line 19.7
"Williams should still enjoy a nice week 1 against a pass defense that, in Weeks 12-18 last year, allowed the 3rd highest passing success rate"
Fantasy Football Today
Week 2 · 2026
8.7
MISS
8.7 pts · startable line 19.7
"Would you rather start Purdy or Caleb Williams? Caleb."
Fantasy Football Today
Week 2 · 2026
8.7
MISS
8.7 pts · startable line 19.7
"Would you rather start Purdy or Caleb Williams? Caleb."
Good Old Boys Fantasy Football
Week 2 · 2026
8.7
MISS
8.7 pts · startable line 19.7
"caleb williams or uh trevor lawrence yeah without a doubt smash yes move on"
ESPN Fantasy Focus Football
Week 2 · 2026
8.7
MISS
8.7 pts · startable line 19.7
"If you have a bear, you should be playing that bear."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 2 · 2026
8.7
MISS
8.7 pts · startable line 19.7
"if you nail the right combo, you could differentiate yourself from the rest of the field"
Fantasy Football Today
Week 2 · 2026
8.7
MISS
8.7 pts · startable line 19.7
"It shouldn't change how you approach your Bears and start them"
Fantasy Football Today
Week 2 · 2026
8.7
MISS
8.7 pts · startable line 19.7
"I'm starting Caleb Williams. No hesitation."
Fantasy Football Today
Week 2 · 2026
8.7
MISS
8.7 pts · startable line 19.7
"I'm starting Caleb Williams. No hesitation."
RotoWire Fantasy Football
Week 2 · 2026
8.7
MISS
8.7 pts · startable line 19.7
"It's Caleb Williams this week."
Fantasy Football Today
Week 2 · 2026
8.7
MISS
8.7 pts · startable line 19.7
"Trevor Lawrence or Caleb Williams? Caleb."
Fantasy Points Podcast
Week 2 · 2026
8.7
MISS
8.7 pts · startable line 19.7
"It felt like almost an impossible to not be great setup."
Fantasy Football Today
Week 1 · 2026
37.3
HIT ✓
37.3 pts · startable line 19.2
"It is Caleb for me"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 1 · 2026
37.3
MISS
37.3 pts · startable line 19.2
"Asking Williams to hit the ground running against a Brian Flores defense in week 1 is probably asking too much, though."