Shows were right on Gardner Minshew 56% of the time in 2025 — 5 of 9 verified calls across 6 shows.
| Fantasy Football Today | 2 of 3 |
| Fantasy Points Podcast | 1 of 2 |
| Fantasy Football Counselor | 2 of 2 |
| Fantasy Alarm Radio | 0 of 1 |
| RotoWire Fantasy Football | 0 of 1 |
| FantasyPros Podcast | 2 pending |
Percentages shown only once a show has 5+ scored calls on this player — below that, counts only.
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 18 · 2025
—
Void
"Minshew could still put up quarterback one numbers this week because the Tennessee pass defense is that bad."
Fantasy Points Podcast
Week 16 · 2025
1.4
MISS
1.4 pts · startable line 18.6
"Mchu has shown a fantasy ceiling at least at times. Uh 18 career games with at least 18 fantasy points. That's only three fewer than Jordan Love in way fewer starts."
Fantasy Alarm Radio
Week 16 · 2025
1.4
MISS
1.4 pts · startable line 18.6
"I would do Mchu over um Quinn."
Fantasy Football Counselor
Week 16 · 2025
1.4
HIT ✓
1.4 pts · startable line 18.6
"I wouldn't start Mchu."
RotoWire Fantasy Football
Week 16 · 2025
1.4
MISS
1.4 pts · startable line 18.6
"Mchu is going to be a great starting option."
Fantasy Football Counselor
Week 16 · 2025
1.4
HIT ✓
1.4 pts · startable line 18.6
"I wouldn't start Minshew, okay?"
Fantasy Football Today
Week 16 · 2025
1.4
MISS
1.4 pts · startable line 18.6
"I love the matchup for Mchu. I love the setup for Mchu. I think he's going to have an opportunity"
Fantasy Football Today
Week 16 · 2025
1.4
HIT ✓
1.4 pts · startable line 18.6
"I would just rather go with Cousins. There's a lot of different areas I'd rather go."
Fantasy Football Today
Week 16 · 2025
1.4
HIT ✓
1.4 pts · startable line 18.6
"I would just rather go with Cousins. There's a lot of different areas I'd rather go."
Fantasy Points Podcast
Week 16 · 2025
1.4
HIT ✓
1.4 pts · startable line 18.6
"I want nothing to do with Minshew."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 6 · 2025
—
Void
"I play Fields just for the rushing equity."