Shows were right on Geno Smith 53% of the time in 2026 — 36 of 68 verified calls across 5 shows.
| FantasyPros Podcast | 30 of 57 · 53% |
| Fantasy Football Today | 6 of 7 · 86% |
| The Ringer Fantasy Football Show | 0 of 2 |
| 4for4 Football Podcast | 0 of 1 |
| Oak | 0 of 1 |
Percentages shown only once a show has 5+ scored calls on this player — below that, counts only.
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
24.5
HIT ✓
24.5 pts · startable line 18.0
"the Smith double stack still has legs and will not have much roster ship"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
24.5
MISS
24.5 pts · startable line 18.0
"Smith is likely turning in another middling quarterback to performance this week."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
24.5
HIT ✓
24.5 pts · startable line 18.0
"Smith could flirt with QB 1 production this week against a Miami secondary"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
24.5
HIT ✓
24.5 pts · startable line 18.0
"Smith could flirt with quarterback one production this week against a Miami secondary"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
24.5
HIT ✓
24.5 pts · startable line 18.0
"Smith could flirt with QW 1 production this week against a Miami secondary"
Fantasy Football Today
Week 7 · 2026
24.5
HIT ✓
24.5 pts · startable line 18.0
"Baker or Geno Smith? Geno. Geno, but that's close."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
24.5
HIT ✓
24.5 pts · startable line 18.0
"Smith could flirt with QB1 production this week against a Miami secondary that has allowed the sixth-most yards per attempt, the second-highest passing touchdown rate, and the highest passing success rate."
Fantasy Football Today
Week 7 · 2026
24.5
HIT ✓
24.5 pts · startable line 18.0
"Would you rather start Patrick Mahomes at Seattle or Geno Smith against the Miami Dolphins? Geno."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
24.5
HIT ✓
24.5 pts · startable line 18.0
"Smith is a solid matchup-based streamer for Week 6."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 6 · 2026
13.0
MISS
13.0 pts · startable line 17.3
"Smith is a solid matchup-based streamer for week six."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 6 · 2026
13.0
MISS
13.0 pts · startable line 17.3
"Smith is a solid matchup-based streamer for week six."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 6 · 2026
13.0
HIT ✓
13.0 pts · startable line 17.3
"Smith is likely turning in another middling quarterback 2 performance this week."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 6 · 2026
13.0
MISS
13.0 pts · startable line 17.3
"Smith is a strong QB 2 this week who could surprise with fringe QB 1 production"
The Ringer Fantasy Football Show
Week 5 · 2026
10.0
MISS
10.0 pts · startable line 22.0
"I'm starting Cam Ward and Geno Smith over Justin Herbert this week"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 5 · 2026
10.0
MISS
10.0 pts · startable line 22.0
"I expect Smith to have time to pick apart this pass defense in week 4. Smith is a solid quarterback 2 who could flirt with quarterback 1 production again this week."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 5 · 2026
10.0
MISS
10.0 pts · startable line 22.0
"Smith is a middling QB 2 this week."
4for4 Football Podcast
Week 5 · 2026
10.0
MISS
10.0 pts · startable line 22.0
"I think Geno Smith could be absolutely electric, especially by then A.D. Mitchell should be back."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 5 · 2026
10.0
MISS
10.0 pts · startable line 22.0
"Smith is a middling QB2 this week."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 5 · 2026
10.0
MISS
10.0 pts · startable line 22.0
"Smith is a middling QB 2 this week."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 5 · 2026
10.0
HIT ✓
10.0 pts · startable line 22.0
"Smith is a middling QB2 this week."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 5 · 2026
10.0
HIT ✓
10.0 pts · startable line 22.0
"Smith is a middling quarterback too this week."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 5 · 2026
10.0
MISS
10.0 pts · startable line 22.0
"Smith is a middling QB2 this week."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 5 · 2026
10.0
HIT ✓
10.0 pts · startable line 22.0
"Smith is a middling quarterback too this week."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 5 · 2026
10.0
MISS
10.0 pts · startable line 22.0
"Smith is a middling QB 2 this week."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 4 · 2026
8.8
MISS
8.8 pts · startable line 18.1
"fantasy players should go right back to the well with the veteran quarterback"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 4 · 2026
8.8
MISS
8.8 pts · startable line 18.1
"Smith is a solid QB 2 who could flirt with QB 1 production again this week."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 4 · 2026
8.8
MISS
8.8 pts · startable line 18.1
"Smith is a solid QB 2 who could flirt with QB 1 production again this week."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 4 · 2026
8.8
MISS
8.8 pts · startable line 18.1
"Smith is a solid QB2 who could flirt with QB1 production again this week"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 4 · 2026
8.8
MISS
8.8 pts · startable line 18.1
"Smith is a strong QB 2 this week, who could surprise with fringe QB 1 production."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 4 · 2026
8.8
MISS
8.8 pts · startable line 18.1
"Smith is a solid QB2 who could flirt with QB1 production again this week."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 4 · 2026
8.8
MISS
8.8 pts · startable line 18.1
"fantasy players should go right back to the well with the veteran quarterback"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 4 · 2026
8.8
MISS
8.8 pts · startable line 18.1
"Smith is a solid QB2 who could flirt with QB1 production again this week."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 4 · 2026
8.8
MISS
8.8 pts · startable line 18.1
"Smith is a solid QB 2 who could flirt with QB 1 production again this week."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 4 · 2026
8.8
MISS
8.8 pts · startable line 18.1
"Smith is a solid QB 2 who could flirt with QB 1 production again this week."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 4 · 2026
8.8
MISS
8.8 pts · startable line 18.1
"Smith is a solid QB2 who could flirt with QB1 production again this week."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 4 · 2026
8.8
MISS
8.8 pts · startable line 18.1
"Smith is a solid QB2 who could flirt with QB1 production again this week"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 4 · 2026
8.8
MISS
8.8 pts · startable line 18.1
"Smith is a solid QB 2 who could flirt with QB 1 production again this week."
Oak
Week 4 · 2026
8.8
MISS
8.8 pts · startable line 18.1
"I don't totally mind Geno Smith"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 4 · 2026
8.8
MISS
8.8 pts · startable line 18.1
"fantasy players should go right back to the well with the veteran quarterback"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"Smith is a strong QB 2 this week who could surprise with fringe QB 1 production."
Fantasy Football Today
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"Geno Smith is getting another favorable matchup. We'll see what – we're recording this before the Bears play on Monday night. But presuming it's still the same Bears defense, Geno Smith looked good."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"Smith is the top quarterback streaming option for Week 4."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"Smith is the top quarterback streaming option for Week 4."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"Smith is a strong QB2 this week who could surprise with fringe QB1 production."
Fantasy Football Today
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"I think Geno Smith's in that low end starting conversation for sure."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"Smith is a strong QB2 this week who could surprise with fringe QB1 production."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"Smith can easily pay off at his cost."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"Smith is a strong QB2 this week who could surprise with fringe QB1 production."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"Smith is a strong QB 2 this week who could surprise with fringe QB 1 production."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"Smith is a strong QB 2 this week, who could surprise with fringe QB 1 production."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"Geno Smith is a viable matchup-based streaming option this week against the Lions"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"Smith is a strong QB 2 this week, who could surprise with fringe QB 1 production."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"I am ranking Smith as a mid-range QB2 against the Lions."
Fantasy Football Today
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"I'm going to go with Geno Smith just based on the matchup and I think we're going to get a good stretch of games from Geno"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"Smith is a strong QB2 this week who could surprise with fringe QB1 production."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"Smith is my preferred option at quarterback in cash games, and a stellar GPP pick too."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"Smith is a strong QB 2 this week who could surprise with fringe QB 1 production."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"Smith is a strong QB 2 this week, who could surprise with fringe QB 1 production."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"Smith is a strong QB 2 this week who could surprise with fringe QB 1 production."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"he could land as a back-end QB1 this week"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"he should be able to cobble together a stat line that should return solid QB 2 value"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"he should be able to cobble together a stat line that should return solid QB 2 value."
Fantasy Football Today
Week 3 · 2026
26.0
HIT ✓
26.0 pts · startable line 20.8
"Assuming Nico Collins is out, who do you like better, CJ Stroud or Geno Smith this week? Geno."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 2 · 2026
15.6
MISS
15.6 pts · startable line 19.7
"Smith should have his first game with over 275 passing yards this year"
The Ringer Fantasy Football Show
Week 2 · 2026
15.6
MISS
15.6 pts · startable line 19.7
"i had to start geno smith in this game"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 2 · 2026
15.6
MISS
15.6 pts · startable line 19.7
"he should be able to cobble together a stat line that should return solid QB 2 value."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 1 · 2026
9.3
MISS
9.3 pts · startable line 19.2
"Behind what looks like a strong Jets offensive line, this should be a year for Smith to see plenty of clean pockets."
Fantasy Football Today
Week 1 · 2026
9.3
MISS
9.3 pts · startable line 19.2
"I'm so matchup heavy that I would start Geno over Jordan love personally."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 1 · 2026
—
Void
"Behind what looks like a strong Jets offensive line, this should be a year for Smith to see plenty of clean pockets."