J.J. McCarthy
QB · NYGShows were right on J.J. McCarthy 29% of the time in 2026 — 4 of 14 verified calls across 6 shows.
By Show
| FantasyPros Podcast | 0 of 8 · 0% |
| Underdog Fantasy Football | 2 of 2 |
| 4for4 Football Podcast | 1 of 1 |
| The Ringer Fantasy Football Show | 0 of 1 |
| Yahoo Fantasy Football Podcast | 0 of 1 |
| ESPN Fantasy Focus Football | 1 of 1 |
Percentages shown only once a show has 5+ scored calls on this player — below that, counts only.
Every Verified Call
Newest firstFantasyPros Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
10.2
MISS
10.2 pts · startable line 18.0
"McCarthy is a solid QB2 this week who could easily post QB1 numbers."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
10.2
MISS
10.2 pts · startable line 18.0
"McCarthy is a solid quarterback 2 this week, who could easily post quarterback 1 numbers"
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
10.2
MISS
10.2 pts · startable line 18.0
"McCarthy is a solid QB2 this week, who could easily post QB1 numbers."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
10.2
MISS
10.2 pts · startable line 18.0
"McCarthy is a solid QB2 this week who could easily post QB1 numbers."
4for4 Football Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
10.2
HIT ✓
10.2 pts · startable line 18.0
"I'm not recommending J.J. McCarthy as a start this week."
Underdog Fantasy Football
Week 7 · 2026
10.2
HIT ✓
10.2 pts · startable line 18.0
"I don't think J.J. McCarthy throws for 200 yards in his game."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
10.2
MISS
10.2 pts · startable line 18.0
"McCarthy is a solid quarterback too this week who could easily post quarterback one numbers."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
10.2
MISS
10.2 pts · startable line 18.0
"McCarthy is a solid quarterback two this week, who could easily post quarterback one numbers."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
10.2
MISS
10.2 pts · startable line 18.0
"McCarthy is a solid quarterback two this week, who could easily post quarterback one numbers."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
10.2
MISS
10.2 pts · startable line 18.0
"McCarthy is a solid quarterback too this week, who could easily post quarterback 1 numbers."
The Ringer Fantasy Football Show
Week 7 · 2026
10.2
MISS
10.2 pts · startable line 18.0
"my i'm sticking with the same game jj mccarthy two touchdowns is 80 to one two passing touchdowns or two rushing touchdowns"
Yahoo Fantasy Football Podcast
Week 7 · 2026
10.2
MISS
10.2 pts · startable line 18.0
"I would be shocked if McCarthy is not starting in this next game"
ESPN Fantasy Focus Football
Week 6 · 2026
17.3
HIT ✓
17.3 pts · startable line 17.3
"I just immediately put McCarthy in the projections for this week. Like, I assume they're going to go with it."
Underdog Fantasy Football
Week 6 · 2026
17.3
HIT ✓
17.3 pts · startable line 17.3
"I would just go with J.J. McCarthy. At least you have a more mobile quarterback."
FantasyPros Podcast
Week 1 · 2026
—
Void
"I am a big believer in his talent, and Kevin of Connell to get the best out of him."